D. Evidence/documents provided by witnesses and other parties

DocumentsSelect Committee reference no.
1.Witness statement from Mrs Sarah KWOK TAM Pui-yi, Former Deputy Secretary for the Civil Service 1 dated 4 March 2009 W1(C)
2.Witness statement from Mr Andrew WONG Ho-yuen, Permanent Secretary for the Civil Service dated 4 March 2009 W2(C)
3.Witness statement from Miss Denise YUE Chung-yee, Secretary for the Civil Service dated 4 March 2009 W3(C)
4.Witness statement from Mr David CHOW Chor-kong, Former Assistant Director (Administration), Housing Branch, Transport and Housing Bureau dated 4 March 2009 W4(C)
5.Witness statement from Mr Thomas CHAN Chun-yuen, Permanent Secretary for Transport and Housing (Housing) dated 4 March 2009 W5(C)
6.Witness statement from Mrs Pearl SIU NG Che-sheung, Chief Executive Officer (Administration), Planning and Lands Branch, Development Bureau dated 4 March 2009 W6(C)
7.Witness statement from Mrs Susan MAK LOK Suet-ling, Former Deputy Secretary for Development (Planning and Lands)1 dated 4 March 2009 W7(C)
8.Witness statement from Mr WONG Kwai-kuen, Chief Executive Officer (Works) Administration, Works Branch, Development Bureau dated 4 March 2009 W8(C)
9.Witness statement from Mr MAK Chai-kwong, Permanent Secretary for Development (Works) dated 4 March 2009 W9(C)
10.Witness statement from Mr PANG Kin-kee, Chairman of the Advisory Committee on Post-service Employment of Civil Servants dated 27 March 2009 W10(C)
11.Witness statement from Dr Elizabeth SHING Shiu-ching, Former Member of the Advisory Committee on Post-service Employment of Civil Servants dated 24 March 2009 W11(C)
12.Witness statement from Mr James Edward THOMPSON, Member of the Advisory Committee on Post-service Employment of Civil Servants W12(C)
13.Witness statement from Ms Marina WONG Yu-pok, Member of the Advisory Committee on Post-service Employment of Civil Servants dated 24 March 2009 W13(C)
14.Witness statement from Mr Simon IP Sik-on, Member of the Advisory Committee on Post-service Employment of Civil Servants dated 26 March 2009 W14(C)
15.Witness statement from Mrs Carrie WONG HO Ka-lai, Secretary to the Advisory Committee on Post-service Employment of Civil Servants and Chief Executive Officer (Pensions) of the Civil Service Bureau dated 26 March 2009 W15(C)
16.Witness statement from Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun dated 23 March 2009 W16(C)
17.Witness statement from Mr Stewart LEUNG Chi-kin dated 23 March 2009 W17(C)
18.Witness statement from Mr LEUNG Chin-man dated 25 March 2009 W18(C)
19.Further information provided by Mr Andrew WONG Ho-yuen, Permanent Secretary for the Civil Service W19(C)
20.Witness statement from Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun dated 2 April 2009 W20(C)
21.Witness statement from Mr Stewart LEUNG Chi-kin dated 2 April 2009 W21(C)
22.Witness statement from Mrs Susan MAK LOK Suet-ling, Former Deputy Secretary for Development (Planning and Lands)1 dated 8 April 2009 W22(C)
23.Witness statement from Mr PANG Kin-kee, Chairman of the Advisory Committee on Post-service Employment of Civil Servants dated 14 April 2009 W23(C)
24.Witness statement from Mrs Carrie WONG HO Ka-lai, Secretary to the Advisory Committee on Post-service Employment of Civil Servants and Chief Executive Officer (Pensions) of the Civil Service Bureau dated 14 April 2009 W24(C)
25.Further information provided by Miss Denise YUE Chung-yee, Secretary for the Civil Service dated 21 April 2009 W25(C)
26.Further information provided by Mr LEUNG Chin-man dated 11 May 2009 W26(C)
27.Further information provided by Mr Thomas CHAN Chun-yuen, Permanent Secretary for Transport and Housing (Housing) W27(C)
28.Witness statement from Mr Marco WU Moon-hoi, Former Deputy Director of Housing/Deputy Secretary for Housing (2), Housing Department dated 7 May 2009 W28(C)
29.Witness statement from Mr Vincent TONG Wing-shing, Former Deputy Director (Development and Construction), Housing Department dated 7 May 2009 W29(C)
30.Witness statement from Mr John Stanley CORRIGALL, Former Deputy Director (Specialist), Lands Department dated 27 April 2009 W30(C)
31.Further information provided by Mr David CHOW Chor-kong, Former Assistant Director (Administration), Housing Branch, Transport and Housing Bureau W31(C)
32.Witness statement from Mr CHUNG Kwok-cheong dated 29 May 2009 W32(C)
33.Further information provided by Mrs Susan MAK LOK Suet-ling, Former Deputy Secretary for Development (Planning and Lands)1 dated 13 May 2009 W33(C)
34.Further information provided by Mr CHUNG Kwok-cheong at the hearing on 4 June 2009 W34(C)
35.Witness statement from Mr John Stanley CORRIGALL, Former Deputy Director (Specialist), Lands Department dated 3 June 2009 W35(C)
36.Further information provided by Miss Denise YUE Chung-yee, Secretary for the Civil Service W37(C)
37.Witness statement from Mr Michael SUEN Ming-yeung, Former Secretary for Housing, Planning and Lands dated 26 June 2009 W38(C)
38.Witness statement from Mr LEUNG Chin-man, Former Permanent Secretary for Housing, Planning and Lands (Housing)/Director of Housing dated 7 July 2009 W39(C)
39.Statement from Mr LEUNG Chin-man, Former Permanent Secretary for Housing, Planning and Lands (Housing)/ Director of Housing W40(C)
40.Statement from Mr LEUNG Chin-man, Former Permanent Secretary for Housing, Planning and Lands (Housing)/ Director of Housing dated 22 July 2009 W41(C)
41.Witness statement from Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun, Developer of the Hunghom Peninsula development dated 30 October 2009 W43(C)
42.Witness statement from Mr Stewart LEUNG Chi-kin, Developer of the Hunghom Peninsula development dated 30 October 2009 W44(C)
43.Further information provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun, Developer of the Hunghom Peninsula development dated 12 November 2009 W45(C)
44.Further information provided by Mr Stewart LEUNG Chi-kin, Developer of the Hunghom Peninsula development dated 12 November 2009 W46(C)
45.Further information provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun, Developer of the Hunghom Peninsula development at the hearing on 17 November 2009 W47(C)
46.Further information provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun and Mr Stewart LEUNG Chi-kin, Developer of the Hunghom Peninsula development dated 31 December 2009 W48(C)
47.Further information provided by Miss Denise YUE Chung-yee, Secretary for the Civil Service W49(C)
48.Further information provided by Mr Andrew WONG Ho-yuen, Permanent Secretary for the Civil Service W50(C)
49.Further information provided by Mr Andrew WONG Ho-yuen, Permanent Secretary for the Civil Service W51(C)
50.List of papers, books, records and documents which the Select Committee has ordered Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun to produce (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R1
51.Records of advertisement/recruitment for a Procurement Manager by New World China Land Limited (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R2
52.Exchange of emails between Ms Lynda NGAN Man-ying on behalf of New World China Land Limited and Mr LEUNG Chin-man and standard terms and conditions of employment of New World China Land Limited staff (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R3
53.Minutes of meeting on 1 August 2008 of the Executive Committee of the Board of Directors of New World China Land Limited (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R4
54.Letter dated 11 August 2008 from New World China Land Limited to the Secretary for the Civil Service (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R5
55.Minutes of meeting on 18 August 2008 of the Executive Committee of the Board of Directors of New World China Land Limited and Termination Agreement between New World China Land Limited and Mr LEUNG Chin-man on 18 August 2008 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R6
56.Announcement dated 1 August 2008 made by New World China Land Limited on the appointment of Mr LEUNG Chin-man as an Executive Director and Deputy Managing Director of New World China Land Limited (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R7
57.Press statement issued by New World China Land Limited on 16 August 2008 relating to the termination of employment contract of Mr LEUNG Chin-man (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R8
58.Announcement dated 18 August 2008 made by New World China Land Limited relating to the termination of the contract between New World China Land Limited and Mr LEUNG Chin-man (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R9
59.Mr LEUNG Chin-man's public statement relating to the resolution of his employment contract with New World China Land Limited (provided by Mr LEUNG Chin-man) R10
60.Letters dated 25 March, 1, 9 and 15 April 2009 from Mr LEUNG Chin-man to the Select Committee in relation to papers, books, records, and documents which the Select Committee has ordered him to produce (provided by Mr LEUNG Chin-man) R11
(revised)
61.Email dated 20 July 2008 from Mr LEUNG Chin-man to Ms Lynda NGAN Man-ying (provided by Mr LEUNG Chin-man) R12
62.Exchange of emails between Ms Joanne MA Ching-tak on behalf of New World China Land Limited and Mr LEUNG Chin-man dated 17 and 18 August 2008 (provided by Mr LEUNG Chin-man) R13
63.List of papers, books, records and documents which the Select Committee has ordered Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun to produce (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R14
64.Letter dated 11 May 2002 from First Star Development Limited to the Housing Department (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R15
65.Letter dated 27 May 2002 from the Housing Department to First Star Development Limited (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R16
66.Letter dated 10 June 2002 from First Star Development Limited to the Director of Housing (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R17
67.Letter dated 21 June 2002 from the Business Director/ Allocation and Marketing of the Housing Department to First Star Development Limited / Supertime Holdings Limited (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R18
68.Letter dated 2 July 2002 from First Star Development Limited to the Chief Secretary for the Administration (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R19
69.Reply letter dated 3 October 2002 from Mr LEUNG Chin-man on behalf of the Chief Secretary for the Administration to First Star Development Limited (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R20
70.Letter dated 11 December 2002 from First Star Development Limited to the Lands Department (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R21
71.Letter dated 12 December 2002 from the Lands Department to First Star Development Limited (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R22
72.Letter dated 16 December 2002 from the Lands Department to First Star Development Limited (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R23
73.Letter dated 19 December 2002 from the Lands Department to First Star Development Limited (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R24
74.Letter dated 23 December 2002 from First Star Development Limited to the Director of Lands (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R25
75.Letter dated 20 February 2003 from First Star Development Limited to the Lands Department on the proposed modification of Kowloon Inland Lot No. 11076 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R27
76.Letter dated 13 March 2003 from First Star Development Limited to the Lands Department (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R28
77.Letter dated 17 January 2004 from the Lands Department to the developer's solicitors on Kowloon Inland Lot No. 11076 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R29
78.Letter dated 26 January 2004 from the developer's solicitors to the Lands Department on proposed lease modification of Kowloon Inland Lot No. 11076 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R30
79.Letter dated 31 January 2004 from the developer's solicitors to the Lands Department on Kowloon Inland Lot No. 11076 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R31
80.Letter dated 3 February 2004 from the Lands Department to the developer's solicitors on Kowloon Inland Lot No. 11076 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R32
81.Letter dated 10 February 2004 from Cheung, Chan & Chung, Solicitors and Notaries to the Legal Advisory and Conveyancing Office of the Lands Department (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R33
82.Letter dated 11 February 2004 from the developer's solicitors to the Lands Department on Kowloon Inland Lot No. 11076 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R34
83.Letter dated 12 February 2004 from the developer's solicitors to the Lands Department on Kowloon Inland Lot No. 11076 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R35
84.Letter dated 12 February 2004 from the Lands Department to the developer's solicitors on Kowloon Inland Lot No. 11076 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R36
85.Letter dated 12 February 2004 from the Lands Department to the developer's solicitors on the mediation (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R37
86.Memorial of an instrument dated 26 February 2004 on lease modification of Kowloon Inland Lot No. 11076 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R38
87.Letter dated 21 January 2004 from the Lands Department to the developer's solicitors on Kowloon Inland Lot No. 11076 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R39
88.Letter dated 30 October 2003 from the Department of Justice to Cheung, Chan & Chung, Solicitors and Notaries (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R40
89.Letter dated 5 November 2003 from Cheung, Chan & Chung, Solicitors and Notaries to the Department of Justice (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R41
90.Letter dated 12 November 2003 from the Department of Justice to Cheung, Chan & Chung, Solicitors and Notaries (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R42
91.Letter dated 25 November 2003 from mediator Mr LEUNG Hing-fung to all parties in HCA 2761/2003 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R43
92.Letter dated 30 December 2003 from the Lands Department to the developer's solicitors on the mediation (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R45
93.Letter dated 8 January 2004 from the Lands Department to the developer's solicitors on the mediation (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R46
94.Letter dated 20 May 2003 from the developer's solicitors to the Chief Executive, the Secretary for Housing, Planning and Lands, the Hong Kong Housing Authority and the Lands Department (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R47
95.Letter dated 12 June 2003 from the Administrative Assistant to Secretary for Housing, Planning and Lands to the developer's solicitors (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R48
96.Writ of Summons issued by the developer of Hunghom Peninsula on 25 July 2003 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R49
97.Acknowledgment of Service of Writ of Summons in HCA 2761/2003 filed by the 2nd Defendant on 5 August 2003 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R50
98.Acknowledgment of Service of Writ of Summons in HCA 2761/2003 filed by the 1st Defendant on 7 August 2003 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R51
99.Defence of the 2nd Defendant (Secretary for Justice (on behalf of the Government of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region)) in respect of the pending proceedings which was filed on 1 December 2003, forwarded by the Department of Justice to the Hong Kong Housing Authority/Housing Department and the Lands Department (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R52
100.Defence of the 1st Defendant (the Hong Kong Housing Authority) of the pending proceedings dated and filed on 2 December 2003 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R53
101.Amended Statement of Claim dated 15 September 2005 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R54
102.Amended Defence of the 1st Defendant (The Hong Kong Housing Authority) filed on 14 October 2005 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R55
103.Amended Defence of the 2nd Defendant (The Secretary for Justice on behalf of the Government) filed on 14 October 2005 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R56
104.Letter dated 22 December 2009 from Sun Hung Kai Properties Limited to the Clerk to Select Committee (provided by Sun Hung Kai Properties Limited) R57
105.Further information provided by Mr CHUNG Kwok-cheong dated 13 August 2009 W42(C)*
106.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr Moses CHENG Mo-chi, Chairman of the Advisory Committee on Post-service Employment of Civil Servants W52(C)*
107.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr David CHOW Chor-kong, Former Assistant Director (Administration), Housing Branch, Transport and Housing Bureau W53(C)*
108.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr Nicky LO Kar-chun, Member of the Advisory Committee on Post-service Employment of Civil Servants W54(C)*
109.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr CHUNG Kwok-cheong W55(C)*
110.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr Marco WU Moon-hoi, Former Deputy Director of Housing/Deputy Secretary for Housing (2), Housing Department W56(C)*
111.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr YEUNG Ka-sing, Member of the Advisory Committee on Post-service Employment of Civil Servants W57(C)*
112.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr Vincent TONG Wing-shing, Former Deputy Director (Development and Construction), Housing Department W58(C)*
113.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mrs Pearl SIU NG Che-sheung, Former Chief Executive Officer (Administration), Planning and Lands Branch, Development Bureau W59(C)*
114.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr Thomas CHAN Chun-yuen, Former Permanent Secretary for Transport and Housing (Housing)/Director of Housing W60(C)*
115.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr MAK Chai-kwong, Former Permanent Secretary for Development (Works) W61(C)*
116.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr WONG Kwai-kuen, Chief Executive Officer (Works) Administration, Works Branch, Development Bureau W62(C)*
117.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr John Stanley CORRIGALL, Former Deputy Director (Specialist), Lands Department W63(C)*
118.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr Michael SUEN Ming-yeung, Former Secretary for Housing, Planning and Lands W64(C)*
119.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Ms Marina WONG Yu-pok, Member of the Advisory Committee on Post-service Employment of Civil Servants W65(C)*
120.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Former Advisory Committee on Post-service Employment of Civil Servants (responsible for considering Mr LEUNG Chin-man's application) W66(C)*
121.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr PANG Kin-kee, Former Chairman of the Advisory Committee on Post-service Employment of Civil Servants W67(C)*
122.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr Simon IP Sik-on, Member of the Advisory Committee on Post-service Employment of Civil Servants W68(C)*
123.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mrs Carrie WONG HO Ka-lai, Secretary to the Advisory Committee on Post-service Employment of Civil Servants and Chief Executive Officer (Pensions) of the Civil Service Bureau W69(C)*
124.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr WAI Chi-sing, Permanent Secretary for Development (Works) W70(C)*
125.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mrs Sarah KWOK TAM Pui-yi, Former Deputy Secretary for the Civil Service 1 W71(C)*
126.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mrs Susan MAK LOK Suet-ling, Former Deputy Secretary for Development (Planning and Lands)1 W72(C)*
127.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun and Mr Stewart LEUNG Chi-kin W73(C)*
128.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr Thomas CHOW Tat-ming, Permanent Secretary for Development (Planning and Lands) W74(C)*
129.Further comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr Thomas CHOW Tat-ming, Permanent Secretary for Development (Planning and Lands) W74(C)-1*
130.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr Andrew WONG Ho-yuen, Permanent Secretary for the Civil Service W75(C)*
131.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Miss Denise YUE Chung-yee, Secretary for the Civil Service W76(C)*
132.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr Duncan Warren PESCOD, Permanent Secretary for Transport and Housing (Housing)/ Director of Housing W77(C)*
133.Comments on relevant extracts of the draft report of the Select Committee from Mr LEUNG Chin-man W78(C)*
134.Draft employment letter from New World China Land Limited to Mr LEUNG Chin-man (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R1(C)*
135.Employment letter dated 30 July 2008 from New World China Land Limited to Mr LEUNG Chin-man (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R2(C)*
136.Notes of understanding by the Mediator dated 21 January 2004 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R3(C)*
137.Letter dated 7 February 2003 from the Lands Department to First Star Development Limited on the proposed modification of Kowloon Inland Lot No. 11076 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R26*
138.Mediation agreement dated 8 December 2003 (provided by Dr Henry CHENG Kar-shun) R44*


* Documents not available for public inspection