Paper for the Bills Committee

Banking (Amendment) Bill 1996
Maximum limits on the amount of value that can be stored on stored value cards

Members of the Bills Committee have expressed interest in the maximum limits on the amount of value that can be stored on stored value cards in other countries. We have now received additional information which is summarised in the attached table for Members’ information. Limits of one kind or another apply to non-bank cards in three countries (Germany, Netherlands and US). These range from HK$702 to HK$1,053, suggesting that a possible exemption threshold for non-bank cards of HK$1,000 does not look out of line.

Hong Kong Monetary Authority
9 October 1996


Stored value card schemes of some major countries

Countries

Austria

Belgium

Denmark

France

Germany

Italy

Japan

Korea

Regulatory approach towards Multi-purpose stored value cards (MPCs)

issuers restricted to banks

issuers restricted to banks based on existing banking law

specific legislation for supervision of prepaid card systems

(no information on whether issuers are restricted to credit institutions)

issuers restricted to credit institutions based on existing banking law

• Currently no legal restrictions on issuance of electronic money

• Amendments to Banking Law being processed to restrict issuers to banks (but providers of smaller card systems would be exempted from a number of requirements)

issuers restricted to banks based on the amended banking law

no specific legislation

(existing "Prepaid Card Law" covers card-based products from consumer protection perspective)

issuers restricted to banks

Existing issuers of MPCs

(name of card scheme)

bank-owned vehicle

(Quick)

bank-owned vehicle

(Proton)

a company jointly owned by a bank-owned vehicle and a non-bank (public telephone co.)

(Danmont)

(pilot project being considered by banks)

banks

(GeldKarte)

non-banks

(PayCard)

group of banks (Cassamat) or bank-controlled company (MINIpay)

(pilot projects being conducted by several entities, which are mainly banks)

banks

Maximum limit* on MPCs

USD 160

USD 150

(targeted at payments below USD15)

USD 51

information not available

USD 270

USD 135

USD 180

(MINIpay)

information not available

USD 62

HKD equivalent at USD1:HKD7.80

HKD 1,248

HKD 1,170

HKD 398

--

HKD 2,106

HKD 1,053

HKD 1,404

--

HKD 484

* These limits represent the features of individual card schemes. In setting these limits, the issuer may have taken account of the limits set by the authorities for regulatory purposes. But we have no detailed information on this.

Countries

Netherlands

Portugal

Singapore

Spain

United Kingdom

United States

Regulatory approach towards Multi-purpose stored value cards (MPCs)

• issuers restricted to credit institutions based on existing banking law

• non-bank issuers have agreed to be subject to supervision

• whether small and local systems should be given exemption has not been decided yet

issuers restricted to banks

issuers restricted to banks having the approval of the Monetary Authority of Singapore under the amended Banking Act

issuers restricted to credit institutions according to Royal Decree

• subscribes to the views of the EMI report that issuers be restricted to credit institutions

• not yet clear whether MPCs will be subject to the provisions of the Banking Act

• no specific legislation on regulation

• proposes to apply part of the Electronic Fund Transfer Act and Regulation E, such as appropriate disclosure, to MPCs. Also proposes to exempt certain types of SVCs with maximum balances of no more than USD 100 from such requirements.

Existing issuers of MPCs

(name of card scheme)

banks

(first stage of Chipknip)

non-bank institution

(Primeur Card)

bank-owned company

(PMB)

(pilot project being undertaken by banks)

banks

(Monedero 4B, Euro 6000 and VisaCash)

banks

(Mondex)

banks or bank-owned vehicle

(Mondex, VisaCash, MasterCard Cash and SmartCash)

Maximum limit* on MPCs

USD 300

USD 90

USD 411

information not available

USD 200-240

USD 715

(for Mondex consumer cards; retailer cards have higher limits)

USD 100

(being the limit under which the MPCs would be exempted from the proposed requirements under Regulation E)

HKD equivalent at USD1:HKD7.80

HKD 2,340

HKD 702

HKD 3,206

--

HKD 1,560-1,872

HKD 5,577

HKD 780

* These limits represent the features of individual card schemes. In setting these limits, the issuer may have taken account of the limits set by the authorities for regulatory purposes. But we have no detailed information on this.


Last Updated on 15 December 1998