Panel on Planning, Lands and Works

Subcommittee to Review the Planning for the
Central Waterfront (including the Tamar Site)

Meeting on
Monday, 3 April 2006, at 4:30 pm
in the Chamber of the Legislative Council Building

Agenda

I.Traffic and environmental issues arising from the current planning for the Central Waterfront and the Tamar development project
(4:30 pm - 6:15 pm)

Meeting with deputations and the Administration

Discussion papers for the meeting

LC Paper No. CB(1)1201/05-06(01)
(issued vide LC Paper No. CB(1)1210/05-06 on 31.3.2006)

-Views of deputations on traffic and environmental issues submitted to the Subcommittee and the Administration's response (position as at 31 March 2006)

LC Paper No. CB(1)855/05-06(01)
(issued on 7.2.2006)

-Summary of views on the Tamar Development Project raised by deputations and in submissions to the Panel on Planning, Lands and Works and Director of Administration's response

LC Paper No. CB(1)855/05-06(02)
(English version issued vide LC Paper No. CB(1)862/05-06 on 8.2.2006, Chinese version issued vide LC Paper No. CB(1)873/05-06 on 8.2.2006)

-Summary of views on the planning for the Central Waterfront raised by deputations and in submissions to the Panel on Planning, Lands and Works and the Administration's response

LC Paper No. CB(1)1201/05-06(02)
(issued vide LC Paper No. CB(1)1210/05-06 on 31.3.2006)

-Administration's response to the requests for information and questions raised at the meeting on 7 March 2006

Deputations and their submissions

  1. Ir Prof William H K LAM
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)1199/05-06(01) - English version only (issued on 29.3.2006))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)511/05-06(08) - English version only (issued on 13.12.2005))

  2. Citizen Envisioning @ Harbour
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)314/05-06(01) (issued on 17.11.2005))

  3. The Hong Kong Institute of Surveyors
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)1201/05-06(03) - English version only (issued on 30.3.2006))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)511/05-06(14) - English version issued on 13.12.2005, Chinese version issued vide LC Paper No. CB(1)631/05-06 on 3.1.2006)

  4. Margaret and Nicholas BROOKE
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)262/05-06(03) - English version only (issued on 10.11.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)511/05-06(04) - English version only (issued on 13.12.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)887/05-06(01) - English version only (issued on 14.2.2006))

  5. Ms Vicki LUKINS
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)364/05-06(03) - English version only (issued on 24.11.2005))

  6. The Hong Kong Institute of Planners
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)836/05-06(05) - Chinese version only (issued on 6.2.2006))

  7. Action Group on Protection of The Harbour
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)511/05-06(06) - Chinese version only (issued on 13.12.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)887/05-06(02) - Chinese version only (issued on 14.2.2006))

  8. Central & Western District Council

  9. The Hong Kong Institution of Engineers
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)527/05-06(02) - English version only (issued on 16.12.2005))

  10. Mr Colin DAWSON
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)262/05-06(02) - English version only (issued on 10.11.2005))

  11. The Hong Kong Institute of Architects
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)577/05-06(01) - Chinese version only (issued on 20.12.2005))

  12. Mr Paul ZIMMERMAN, Convenor, Designing Hong Kong Habour District and Principal, The Experience Group, Limited
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)1210/05-06(01) - English version only (issued on 31.3.2006))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)235/05-06(01) - English version only (issued on 7.11.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)511/05-06(03) - English version only (issued on 13.12.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)836/05-06(01) - English version only (issued on 6.2.2006))

  13. Dr Bill BARRON
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)511/05-06(09) - English version only (issued on 13.12.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)836/05-06(04) - English version only (issued on 6.2.2006))

  14. Save Our Shorelines
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)364/05-06(10) - English version only (issued on 24.11.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)527/05-06(04) (issued on 16.12.2005))

  15. Mr Winston CHU
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)1210/05-06(02) - English version only (issued on 31.3.2006))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)325/05-06(05) - English version only (issued on 21.11.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)511/05-06(01) (issued on 13.12.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)527/05-06(03) (issued on 16.12.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)607/05-06(01) - English version only (issued on 22.12.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)855/05-06(03) - English version issued on 7.2.2006, Chinese version issued vide LC Paper No. CB(1)862/05-06 on 8.2.2006)

  16. Civic Exchange
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)325/05-06(04) - English version only (issued on 21.11.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)511/05-06(02) - English version only (issued on 13.12.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)855/05-06(04) - English version only (issued on 7.2.2006))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)887/05-06(03) - English version only (issued on 14.2.2006))

  17. Clear The Air
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)1199/05-06(03) - English version only (issued on 29.3.2006))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)325/05-06(02) - English version only (issued on 21.11.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)511/05-06(13) - English version only (issued on 13.12.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)527/05-06(05) - Chinese version only (issued on 16.12.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)527/05-06(06) - English version only (issued on 16.12.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)836/05-06(02) - English version only (issued on 6.2.2006))

  18. Society For Protection Of The Harbour
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)325/05-06(06) - English version only (issued on 21.11.2005))

  19. WWF Hong Kong
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)364/05-06(11) - English version only (issued on 24.11.2005))

  20. Mr John BATTEN
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)364/05-06(04) - English version only (issued on 24.11.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)511/05-06(10) - English version only (issued on 13.12.2005))

  21. Mr Norman de BRACKINGHE
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)1199/05-06(02) - English version only (issued on 29.3.2006))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)364/05-06(05) - English version only (issued on 24.11.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)511/05-06(05) - English version only (issued on 13.12.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)924/05-06(02) - English version only (issued on 16.2.2006))

  22. Friends Of The Harbour
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)325/05-06(03) - English version only (issued on 21.11.2005))
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)511/05-06(07) - English version only (issued on 13.12.2005))

  23. Dr Adrian RAPER
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)325/05-06(10) - English version only (issued on 21.11.2005))

  24. Mr Steve CHAN, Wan Chai District Council Member
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)511/05-06(16) - Chinese version issued on 13.12.2005, English version issued vide LC Paper No. CB(1)527/05-06 on 16.12.2005)
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)887/05-06(04) - Chinese version only (issued on 14.2.2006))

  25. Friends of the Earth (HK)
    (LC Paper No. CB(1)527/05-06(07)(issued on 16.12.2005))

  26. Hong Kong Construction Industry Employees General Union
II.The way forward
(6:15 pm - 6:25 pm)

LC Paper No. CB(1)1078/05-06(01)
(Chinese version only)(issued on 5.3.2006)

-Letter dated 7 March 2006 from Dr Hon KWOK Ka-ki

III.Any other business
(6:25 pm - 6:30 pm)

(A list of other relevant papers previously issued is in the Appendix.)

Council Business Division 1
Legislative Council Secretariat
3 April 2006

Appendix

Other relevant papers previously issued

Background information on the Tamar development project and Central waterfront

LC Paper No. CB(1)118/05-06(05)
(issued on 21.10.2005)(for the meeting of the Panel on Planning, Lands and Works on 25 October 2005)

-Approved Central District (Extension) Outline Zoning Plan No. S/H24/6

LC Paper No. CB(1)921/04-05(02)
(issued vide LC Paper No. CB(1)946/04-05 on 21.2.2005)(for the meetings of the Panel on Planning, Lands and Works on 22 February, 26 April and 25 October 2005)

-Background brief on "Central and Wan Chai reclamation" prepared by the Legislative Council Secretariat

LC Paper No. CB(1)289/05-06(05)
(issued vide LC Paper No. CB(1)325/05-06 on 21.11.2005)(for the meeting of the Panel on Planning, Lands and Works on 22 November 2005)

-Background brief on "Future development on the Tamar site" prepared by the Legislative Council Secretariat

Papers provided by the Administration

LC Paper No. CB(1)123/05-06(06)
(issued on 24.10.2005)(for the meeting of the Panel on Planning, Lands and Works on 25 October 2005)

-Information paper on "Central Reclamation Phase III - Land Uses of the Reclamation Area"

LC Paper No. CB(1)289/05-06(03)
(issued on 16.11.2005)(for the meeting of the Panel on Planning, Lands and Works on 22 November 2005)

-Information paper on "Re-launch of Tamar Development Project"

LC Paper No. CB(1)289/05-06(04)
(issued on 16.11.2005)(for the meeting of the Panel on Planning, Lands and Works on 22 November 2005)

-Supplementary information provided by the Administration on issues relating to the Tamar development project raised in the letters of 26 October and 3 November 2005 from the Panel on Planning, Lands and Works

LC Paper No. CB(1)444/05-06(01)
(issued on 1.12.2005)

-Administration's response to the motion passed at the meeting of the Panel on Planning, Lands and Works on 25 October 2005 on the land uses of the reclamation area under Central Reclamation Phase III

LC Paper No. CB(1)579/05-06(01)
(English version issued on 20.12.2005, Chinese version issued vide LC Paper No. CB(1)607/05-06 on 22.12.2005)

-Letter dated 19 December 2005 from the Director of Administration providing further information about the Tamar development project

LC Paper No. CB(1)702/05-06(01)
(issued on 13.1.2006)

-Administration's response to major issues on "Tamar development project and land-use planning for Central Reclamation Phase III" raised by deputations at the special meeting of the Panel on Planning, Lands and Works on 17 December 2005

LC Paper No. CB(1)1014/05-06(01)
(issued on 4.3.2006)

-Information paper provided by the Administration in response to the questions and requests for information raised at the meeting on 9 February 2006

Submissions received by the Panel on Planning, Lands and Works

LC Paper No. CB(1)262/05-06(01)
(English version only)(issued on 10.11.2005)

-Email dated 9 November 2005 from Mr Peter MILLWARD

LC Paper No. CB(1)289/05-06(06)
(English version only)(issued on 16.11.2005)

-Email dated 15 November 2005 from Mr Peter MILLWARD

LC Paper No. CB(1)297/05-06(01)
(English version only)(issued on 15.11.2005)

-Letter dated 14 November 2005 from Harbour Business Forum

LC Paper No. CB(1)325/05-06(01)
(English version only)(issued on 21.11.2005)

-Email dated 17 November 2005 from Mr Gerry KIPLING

LC Paper No. CB(1)325/05-06(07)
(English version only)(issued on 21.11.2005)

-Email dated 20 November 2005 from Ms Michelle GARNAUT

LC Paper No. CB(1)325/05-06(08)
(English version only)(issued on 21.11.2005)

-Email dated 21 November 2005 from Mr Chris WATTS

LC Paper No. CB(1)325/05-06(09)
(English version only)(issued on 21.11.2005)

-Email dated 21 November 2005 from Ms Karen POLSON

LC Paper No. CB(1)325/05-06(11)
(English version only)(issued on 21.11.2005)

-Email dated 21 November 2005 from Ms Taura EDGAR

LC Paper No. CB(1)325/05-06(12)
(English version only)(issued on 21.11.2005)

-Email dated 21 November 2005 from Ms Rachel PLECAS

LC Paper No. CB(1)325/05-06(13)
(English version only)(issued on 21.11.2005)

-Letter dated 21 November 2005 from Ms Michelle VOSPER, Hong Kong Representative, Asian Cultural Council

LC Paper No. CB(1)364/05-06(01)
(English version only)(issued on 24.11.2005)

-Email dated 21 November 2005 from Mr Adrian FUNG

LC Paper No. CB(1)364/05-06(02)
(English version only)(issued on 24.11.2005)

-Submission dated 21 November 2005 from Ms Bethan GREAVES

LC Paper No. CB(1)364/05-06(06)
(English version only)(issued on 24.11.2005)

-Submission dated 21 November 2005 from Mr Tian TSE

LC Paper No. CB(1)364/05-06(07)
(English version only)(issued on 24.11.2005)

-Submission dated 21 November 2005 from Ms Winnifred Che-yeng WONG

LC Paper No. CB(1)364/05-06(08)
(English version only)(issued on 24.11.2005)

-Email dated 21 November 2005 from Mr Anthony MACKAY

LC Paper No. CB(1)364/05-06(09)
(English version only)(issued on 24.11.2005)

-Email dated 21 November 2005 from Mr Tim STEINERT

LC Paper No. CB(1)364/05-06(12)
(Chinese version only)(issued on 24.11.2005)

-Submission dated 22 November 2005 from Dr Hon KWOK Ka-ki

LC Paper No. CB(1)511/05-06(11)
(English version only)(issued on 13.12.2005)

-Letter dated 10 December 2005 from The Hong Kong Institute of Landscape Architects

LC Paper No. CB(1)511/05-06(12)
(English version only)(issued on 13.12.2005)

-Letter dated 10 December 2005 from ms Santa RAYMOND

LC Paper No. CB(1)511/05-06(15)
(English version only)(issued on 13.12.2005)

-Email dated 25 November 2005 from Mr Peter WOOD

LC Paper No. CB(1)527/05-06(01)
(English version only)(issued on 16.12.2005)

-Submission dated December 2005 from The Hong Kong Construction Association Ltd

LC Paper No. CB(1)590/05-06(01)
(English version only)(issued on 21.12.2005)

-Submission dated 20 December 2005 from The Real Estate Developers Association of Hong Kong on "Tamar development project and land-use planning for Central Reclamation Phase III"

Submissions received by the Subcommittee

LC Paper No. CB(1)836/05-06(03)
(English version only)(issued on 6.2.2006)

-Submission from Mr Tim STEINERT

LC Paper No. CB(1)836/05-06(06)
(English version only)(issued on 6.2.2006)

-Submission from Ms Santa RAYMOND

LC Paper No. CB(1)855/05-06(05)
(English version only)(issued on 7.2.2006)

-Submission from Mr Rob PENDLETON

LC Paper No. CB(1)855/05-06(06)
(English version only)(issued on 7.2.2006)

-Submission from Hong Kong Sustainable Development Forum

LC Paper No. CB(1)862/05-06(01)
(English version only)(issued on 8.2.2006)

-Submission from Mr David FRIEDLAND

LC Paper No. CB(1)887/05-06(05)
(English version only)(issued on 14.2.2006)

-Speaking note of Mr Gerry KIPLING

LC Paper No. CB(1)924/05-06(01)
(English version only)(issued on 16.2.2006)

-Submission from The Hong Kong Institute of Real Estate Administration

LC Paper No. CB(1)1050/05-06(01)
(issued on 8.3.2006)

-Joint press release dated 6 March 2006 from Civic Exchange, Society For Protection Of The Harbour, Friends Of The Harbour, Designing Hong Kong Harbour District, Action Group on Protection of The Harbour and Hong Kong Alternatives

Council Business Division 1
Legislative Council Secretariat
3 April 2006